Graeme Kenyon wrote:
Dom, just to make it clear, any opinion I might have about JR is of little value because I am in the beginner category with that particular rig, same as you. All I can tell you about that is that you are in the right place to get the best advice, if that’s the rig you want to go with.
What I meant to say is that with a bit of improvisation you can have some fun learning how to make that very nice motor boat sail, if you want to. You might be still a little distance away just yet from knowing what sort of rig you want – if indeed you even really want to sail - so why not just start with a simple home-made lug sail on a mast you can lift in and out, and a blade you can lash onto the outboard leg.
Imagine you are lost at sea with a broken-down motor and have to make a jury rig with what is available and at hand. You will be able to make that thing sail alright, that’s for sure. Pick your weather, have some fun and see what you can learn. Its called “messing about in boats….” its all good fun and that might be as far as you decide to go with it.
That hull shape won’t stop you from being able to sail moderately well, even to windward with a bit more lateral plane, which does not have to be a foil. But just don’t forget that if you have to carry that motor, then quite a big chunk of your total weight is right at the back and up over the waterline which is far from ideal and pretty much limits what you are going to be able to do, whatever rig you have, so don’t get too carried away with sail area or too ambitious about sailing performance until you have got a feel for what you are about.
I don’t have a reputation to lose so I will venture an opinion on sail area by referring you to the website https://www.nztya.nz/trailer-yacht-designs.html where you can see a brief summary of about 150 designs of trailer yachts, some of them roughly comparable with your boat’s length and displacement, and you might see that some of the smaller ones have a sail area of around 12-15 sq m.
But these boats have their weight distributed much more sensibly for sailing than you, so I think you might be advised to try the idea first with quite a bit less than that and just see how you get on.
Be safe and have fun.
(I can't help adding this - there hasn't been much response apart from Annie and it might be a bit unfair to expect the junk experts to come up with a one-iteration step that will take you straight to an optimal plan for mast and rig - which is maybe what you are hoping for - when you are presenting such an out-of-the-ordinary platform to start with. That doesn't mean for one minute that it can't be done, but maybe you should be thinking of getting there step by step and just enjoying the journey. Or maybe you might decide to look around for a trailer yacht (do you have them? We have heaps of them here in New Zealand and they can be had cheap here now - Mauritius sounds like an ideal place for such a boat.) Putting a junk rig on an old trailer yacht would bring you a flood of good advice from experienced people who have done that very successfully. You can still have a small outboard motor. Have two boats - one for sailing really well under junk rig - and one for exciting fun under power!)
Hi Graeme and thank you for your generosity with your time and advises. Some quick answers to your above comments, not necessarily in their initial order.(1) My mind is set on a junk rig for the many reasons that both you and I know which I wont list. (2) Two boats are not an option because of the high cost of renting an additional berth at the marina (the only marina in Mauritius!). (3) I don't mind being snubbed by the experts, and I agree with you that the best route for me to take is an iterative design approach. Trial-and-error mixed with determination and common sense can go a long way. Having said that, I would like to avoid the major (and potentially unsafe) blunders of the novice JR converter. You already answered 90% of what I was looking for, namely whether this hull can sail with a junk rig or not, and I thank you for it.
There a re a few locals that repair kitesurf and windsurf sails, and I can have a relatively inexpensive undersized lateen sail made, to try out the boat behavior. Another advantage of the tabernacle design on a reinforced bow deck, is that in the event of a truly unbalanced helm, I can probably adjust the mast position without major structural changes.
Also, you are absolutely right about being able to rig a boat in case of an emergency, and this is also the reason I am readying this boat to sail. I am not exactly what you call a 'prepper', but consider this: Mauritius has 1.2M people and ranks 19th in world population density. The island imports almost all its food and energy from abroad. Having an autonomous exit pod in case of real emergency hardly seems superfluous.