I bought a Freedom 33, (currently "Footloose") last month and I've been working up a junk ketch design when Paul posted the starter here. Fortunately, the previous owner scrapped the old sails and invested much of his refit efforts on non-sailing works.
Full disclosure: I've done most of the number-crunching with an AI (Claude), working from PJR and Arne's previous designs / documents. I work with AI in my day job and that makes me suitably skeptical - I've caught it making a variety of mistakes that even a novice junkie who's read through PJR a couple of times knows are wrong.
So I've had it re-derive PJR's own worked examples to check its arithmetic. But that only shows the sums are right, not that the design is sensible, which is why I'm posting here.
When I was getting ready to post about my efforts here (which do not differ that much from what Arne's design here), I saw this discussion about Paul's Freedom 35 and asked it to reconsider.
How my design differs from Arne's sketch, and why:
- Two identical sails, 33.1 m² each (66.2 m² total), against his 39.2 / 28.7 m². Every batten, boom and yard is one length, so one spare covers them all, and one set of patterns makes both sails. Reefing both together keeps the CE 2.8–4.3% of LWL ahead of the CLR all the way down.
- B = 4.00 m on both, against his 5.00 / 4.10 m. I'm attempting to source carbon tubes for not too absurd price (compared to aluminum), and this seems like it might be the sweet spot, and give a little more clearance between the sails and a slightly better angle on the mizzen sheet.
- Higher aspect ratio, 2.46. I measured the masts on the boat at 11.9 / 11.3 m above the deck. With the deck heights off the drawing, that puts the mastheads at 13.2 / 12.9 m above the waterline, taller than in his sketch. With B capped at 4 m, the area has to come from height.
- Seven panels plus one 35° head panel, rather than two fanned head panels. Every batten is sheeted, so even reefed down to the last panel the sail stays under control.
- 25% balance on both sails. The forward limit is the stem: the main's tack already sits about 0.2 m ahead of the stem head. The main sheets to a new traveller on the coachroof, which clears the mizzen.
- Cambered panels by Arne's method, at 8% camber.
Does anything here look wrong to experienced eyes? In particular: the main's tack forward of the stem, balance on a cat ketch, and whether a single head panel is a mistake?