.

Freedom 35 Cat Ketch junk rig conversion

<< First  < Prev   1   2   Next >  Last >> 
  • 21 Nov 2026 18:18
    Reply # 13789125 on 13765638

    Mine is actually the deep fixed keel (non-centerboard) version, which I gather was the English version.

    While I'm pretty new to sailing, I spent a fair bit of time this summer on friends' Bermudan rigs with no flying sails, just sitting on the water waiting for wind. That's definitely part of my motivation for wanting a good bit of sail area up high.


    Jan - I had actually considered doing an SJR - I think my bots skewed away from that as a result of there being more recent active discussions / posts on here about cambered sails than split, and that they seem to be more widely tested and slightly simpler to sew and rig.


    David - I'd actually gone back and forth on whether to size the sails the same and be able to cut and sew the same sail twice. I was inclined to keep them both the same size, but have the main sit slightly higher as a result of the taller mast, so that there's more clearance under the boom when it's going over the cabin roof. There's already plenty of clearance under the mizzen boom as the mizzen mast sits just in front of the companionway cover.


    James - The Freedom cat ketch's  do have most of the benefits of a junk already. As the previous owner scrapped the original sails that probably were pretty ragged out, I'm in the market for a new suite of sails. One of the things that made this particular boat appealing was that I wasn't going to be replacing existing sails in good condition.

    I did search but haven't had much luck finding suitable secondhand options - these boats are rare enough that there don't seem to be many around. While I have found some secondhand options that I  could make work, I'd be losing quite a bit of sail area for the ones that I've found so far, and given the light winds spring through fall in the Puget Sound (where I expect to be doing most of my sailing for the next couple of years at least). I'm rather wary of going down to smaller sails. It does seem like the material costs, even with carbon battens, of a junk sail versus a new bermudan main and mizzen would be about the same, albeit with quite the investment of labor to sew up junk sails. I also was searching for a freedom 33 specifically with a view to converting it to a junk rig rather than staying with the existing wishbones.


    Paul Gardham - I just took a closer look at your profile photo of Boo Baboo and realized that the SJR design I was playing around with what looks very similar to what you have, I was wondering if you can share the design measurements, and if there's anything you're considering changing when you sew the next set?


    Paul Usher - Sorry about hijacking your thread :)  But I am  looking forward to sharing our build and sailing experiences.  

  • 21 Nov 2026 17:34
    Reply # 13789110 on 13765638

    I hope this isn't a heresy, but don't these cat ketches have most of the benefits of a junk already? I've not sailed one, but they seem to have the same easy reefing, lack of standing rigging, easy tacking etc. 

    Given the cost/effort to convert, what is the driver for doing so?


  • 21 Nov 2026 15:05
    Reply # 13789071 on 13765638

    As Winnie the Pooh would probably say: "to my little bear brain, the AI ​​solution is very reminiscent of SJR."

    What do Paul G and Slieve say to this?


    Regards - Jan

    Last modified: 21 Nov 2026 15:12 | Anonymous member
  • 21 Nov 2026 10:46
    Reply # 13789021 on 13765638

    Campbell,

    I agree with Arne. The basic concept of going for as high an AR as the masts will permit is good, and also the equal length battens and yards. That should result in a good rig for your Puget Sound/Strait of Georgia/Inside Passage cruising area (particularly in the lighter winds in summer).

    But you might consider increasing the lead by adjusting the luff lengths  - making the fore sail just a little higher than the after sail while keeping the batten and yard lengths and the total area the same. The Benford dories are like this, albeit as schooners, not ketches.  

    I think you'll need upper and lower sheets at this AR - Two 3:1 sheets controlling two groups of four sheeted points on each sail. Otherwise twist will be too much of a problem when deeply reefed.

  • 21 Nov 2026 10:01
    Reply # 13789017 on 13765638
    Anonymous member (Administrator)

    Campbell,

    your access to tall, strong and light  carbon masts changes the equation quite radically. With carbon masts available, the sky is the limit.
    In that perspective, your rig looks good to me. The only uncertainty is about the Lead; the distance of the CE forward of the CLR. I am not sure how the centreboard will affect the CLR, compared to on the fixed keel of the British-built version.
    My armchair guess is that the first reef you will take is in the mizzen. That is not the end of the world.

    Good luck!

    Arne


    Last modified: 21 Nov 2026 10:03 | Anonymous member (Administrator)
  • 21 Nov 2026 01:53
    Reply # 13788952 on 13765638

    I bought a Freedom 33, (currently "Footloose") last month and I've been working up a junk ketch design when Paul posted the starter here. Fortunately, the previous owner scrapped the old sails and invested much of his refit efforts on non-sailing works.


    Full disclosure: I've done most of the number-crunching with an AI (Claude), working from PJR and Arne's previous designs / documents. I work with AI in my day job and that makes me suitably skeptical - I've caught it making a variety of mistakes that even a novice junkie who's read through PJR a couple of times knows are wrong. 

    So I've had it re-derive PJR's own worked examples to check its arithmetic. But that only shows the sums are right, not that the design is sensible, which is why I'm posting here.

    When I was getting ready to post about my efforts here (which do not differ that much from what Arne's design here), I saw this discussion about  Paul's Freedom 35 and asked it to reconsider.

    How my design differs from Arne's sketch, and why:

    - Two identical sails, 33.1 m² each (66.2 m² total), against his 39.2 / 28.7 m². Every batten, boom and yard is one length, so one spare covers them all, and one set of patterns makes both sails. Reefing both together keeps the CE 2.8–4.3% of LWL ahead of the CLR all the way down.

    - B = 4.00 m on both, against his 5.00 / 4.10 m. I'm attempting to source carbon tubes for not too absurd price (compared to aluminum), and this seems like it might be the sweet spot, and give a little more clearance between the sails and a slightly better angle on the mizzen sheet. 

    - Higher aspect ratio, 2.46. I measured the masts on the boat at 11.9 / 11.3 m above the deck. With the deck heights off the drawing, that puts the mastheads at 13.2 / 12.9 m above the waterline, taller than in his sketch. With B capped at 4 m, the area has to come from height. 

    - Seven panels plus one 35° head panel, rather than two fanned head panels. Every batten is sheeted, so even reefed down to the last panel the sail stays under control.

    - 25% balance on both sails. The forward limit is the stem: the main's tack already sits about 0.2 m ahead of the stem head. The main sheets to a new traveller on the coachroof, which clears the mizzen.

    - Cambered panels by Arne's method, at 8% camber.


    Does anything here look wrong to experienced eyes? In particular: the main's tack forward of the stem, balance on a cat ketch, and whether a single head panel is a mistake?

    1 file
    Last modified: 21 Nov 2026 02:08 | Anonymous member
  • 03 Nov 2026 14:23
    Reply # 13768200 on 13765638

    Thanks Arne, this kick start is very much appreciated!

  • 02 Nov 2026 14:58
    Reply # 13767128 on 13765638
    Anonymous member (Administrator)

    Now I have had a go on trying to design a ketch JR for this Freedom 35.  The ‘elephant in the room’ is as always how to find space for sheeting the mainsail without fouling the sheets. To achieve this, I have drawn the mainsail with almost maximum mast balance, but with minimum mast balance in the mizzen. I hope the mainsail will work with a central sheet on deck. One may even push the boom a bit forward until the luff and leech stands parallel with the main mast.

    I guess I would suggest dividing the mainsheet into an upper and lower part, to keep better control of the twist with the sail reefed.

    The mizzen will have a terribly steep sheet. Now I see that BOTM, November 2026, Terrapin appears to have separate port-starboard sheeting on her mizzen. Maybe that would be the way to do it here as well?
    Have a look.

    Arne

    (full size sailplan under Arne's sketches, section 9-29)
  • 02 Nov 2026 08:42
    Reply # 13766957 on 13765638
    Anonymous member (Administrator)

    From Sailboat Data it appears that the Freedom 33 has a shallower keel plus a cb. while the Freedom 35 has a slightly deeper keel with a more sloping sole ( more 'drag'), but without the cb.

    The masts seem to have 1-2 degree aft drag. Is this the case when the sails are not set as well? It's no big deal; they may well be used as they are.

    Arne

  • 01 Nov 2026 17:02
    Reply # 13766467 on 13765638

    Hi Paul,
    I’m the current owner of Pelican, the freedom 33 Cat Ketch previously owned by Pete Hill.

    I bought her from Roy Denton who had named her Ying Zhou.

    She is now called Boo Baboo.

    When I bought her she was still a ketch with Pete Hills hinged batten sails on her, they

    were quite tired and tore quite badly whilst sailing home from Scotland.

     I decided to try Split  Junk Rig on her. Mindful of the fact that SJR had not been tried for both 

    sails On a multimasted boat before, I made initial prototypes out of polytarp to limit the cost if the experiment failed.

    Because of the increased balance of SJR sails The geometry dictated a switch from

    Ketch to Schooner configuration.

    I have been  delighted with the results. I haven’t yet had the time to make her
    permanent suit of sales from better cloth, but have been amazed that the poly tarp

    Has held up for two seasons.

    I’m going to finish the new sails this winter, And once that is done, have promised

    Kevin a write up for the magazine.

    My contact details are in the directory,Do get in touch if you’d like to discuss further.


    paul

    ps- the freedom 35 and 33 cat Ketches are the same boat, the 33’s were made in America, the 

    35’s in the UK.


    Last modified: 01 Nov 2026 17:05 | Anonymous member
<< First  < Prev   1   2   Next >  Last >> 
       " ...there is nothing - absolutely nothing - half so much worth doing as simply messing about in junk-rigged boats" 
                                                               - the Chinese Water Rat

                                                              Site contents © the Junk Rig Association and/or individual authors

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software