David and Annie.
I am both surprised and not surprised to read about the high loads on the luff/throat hauling parrel, that you describe. Johanna’s sail, at 48sqm (AR=1.87), is not much smaller than that of Footprints, but the forces on the THP are quite human, with no need for winches ( I sailed her in F5 winds, with her new owner, a couple of weeks ago). On my newer Frøken Sørensen (20sqm/AR=1.95) the forces in the THP are very light as the relatively taller mast has let me attach the slingpoint about 5% aft of the yard’s midpoint, giving a bit peak halyard effect.
I wonder if the problems you describe could be related to the special planform of the Fantail sails as these are very low and wide (AR= 1.54?). The sheet forces on such sails will work on a very long lever, and thus try to “un-peak up” the yard.
Arne
PS: Ah, yes ,Gary, that bolt was asking for trouble. On my last two junks the halyard has been connected to the yard via a sling (kind of rolling hitch). "Slingpoint", you know.
PPS: Could I suggest you try this sheet setup? It gives good anti-twist. Its only drawback is that it is only 3-part, but that should be no problem on Redwing's sail. The 3-part sheeting produces much less resistance when you are hoisting the sail.
(click on it to zoom in)